We take many things for granted in life – health, shelter, water, food, and yes… comforters. I’ve been on a quest for a new one for months and you’d think I was pursuing the Hope Diamond or Ark of the Covenant. Why is Comforter Land playing such hardball this time? Has bedding changed or have I?
The problem seemed easy: I’d find a pretty bed cover. It would be delivered and I’d love it.
Instead, things went horribly wrong.
I ordered the first one, received it, and rejoiced. The fabric was plush and soft, but with enough heft to get us through winter. I loved the warm taupe color. I placed it on top of the sheets. Done.
Two mornings later I was sipping tea in bed when I looked down at my arms and gasped. They were covered in red, angry-looking hives. So were my legs and torso.
“My God!” I said to my husband, Randy. “What’s happening??!” He looked aghast, like I’d just contracted beri beri. Then I remembered. I had loved this new comforter so much I had skipped the usual first wash. Maybe I was allergic to some chemical used in treating the fabric.
That morning, using rubber gloves, I pulled the spread off the bed and back into its box. Thank God, the rash went away in days, and I returned the comforter — from then on known as the evil comforter – back to whence it came.
The second one arrived a few weeks later. I had seen it in a catalog, loving its earthy “jute-colored” fabric in a minimalist style.
At first all seemed fine. The box was big as most are, but when I went to move it toward the master bedroom, it wouldn’t budge. And I mean…it wouldn’t budge. An uneasy feeling descended. How heavy was this thing?
I finally had to ask my son Paul to help push it. Even my 26-year old who works in a commercial kitchen and lifts heavy objects every day, struggled under the weight of this…blanket? What did they put in this for stuffing? Lead? Rocks? Cement? Would I have to feed and water it once a week?
In the master bedroom, Paul and I extricated it from the box (to much huffing and puffing) and lay it on the bed. Winded, I looked it over, expecting something chic and minimalistic. Instead, I found an army-issue pup tent from World War I retrofitted into a sad, depressing comforter-like… thing.
Since Paul and I didn’t have the will to pull this creature off and cram it back into its box, Randy and I slept under it that night. This was one of those times my husband came into bed later, so I was interested to see if he’d notice anything “different.” (That’s the good thing about men. They can be oblivious to this stuff).
“What the hell is this!!?” was the first thing he said the next morning, grimacing and poking at the burlap-like fabric. “I feel like I’m in lock-up.”
Another return it was. Thank God, the department store was close by. And even though I bought the comforter online, there was no refund for shipping — which judging by its size and heft – would’ve cost millions of dollars. So for the price of nachos at the food court, I bribed poor beleaguered Paul to once again, help me lug this thing back to the store.
The third comforter had to be the charm, I decided.
This one I bought at one of those upscale bedding shops. Within days it arrived. And when I gave the box that all-important “push” test to the master bedroom, it glided like silk. Phew.
I lay the comforter on the bed and inspected, ready to fall in love, but something felt off, something I couldn’t put my finger on. This comforter was the right size, the right weight. It was well made. Then I figured out what was wrong. If the other “prison camp” comforter was too sad, this one was too… happy?
The colors were a little too bright, the pattern too earnest and eager. My God, since when did I need emotional nuance in my bedding?
I tried to return it, but was told it would cost $70. Then I called the company and a lovely woman said if I left the package on my front porch, UPS would take it, free of charge.
And that’s where it sits now, this large cardboard box outside, taunting me, a testament to my inability to perform the most basic task.
I know my comforter is out there somewhere. But where? And when I finally find it, I can promise you this, I’ll never take bedding for granted again.
Have you had trouble finding the perfect… something? Comments are always welcome and if you liked, please share.
To have posts delivered to your in-box, just press here. Thank you.
Diane
Ugh. Bedding-The Adventure Continues. Wishing you luck, because it really is absurdly important!
Laurie Stone
Diane, Yes, it’s a quest that never seems to end.
Carol Ann Cassara
OMGosh. What a story! Yes, I bought one I love some years ago from Macy’s. However, it was not launderable because it didn’t have a zip cover. Into the closet it went. Then, I brought it to my hometown and had a great seamstress I know slit the semams, put big buttonholes and buttons on 2 sides so I could remove the inside and launder the cover. It’s got new life! But that’s what it took.
Of course,….it’s very wrinkleable. … Nothing’s perfect any more….
Laurie Stone
Carol, Leave it to you to find a creative solution!
Diane
I have now succumbed to the ‘European’ method. A bottom sheet with only a feather tic (duvet) on top. I change out the duvet cover every week and everyone is happy! Of course, saying the word, ‘duvet’ always makes me giggle. But that is a story for another time!
Good luck in your search!
Laurie Stone
Diane, Duvet is kind of a funny word. My duvets always end up hopefully twisted with the quilt wedged down at the bottom. Maybe I should give it another try.
Susan F
Why is bedding so hard? I purchased a comforter online for our guest bed. Looks lovely, but smelled dusty until had been washed numerous times??!!?
Laurie Stone
Susan, That’s really strange, especially for new bedding.
Janeane M Davis
You poor baby! I hope you find the comforter of your dreams soon. I think everyone can identify with the issue of wanting something to arrive only to be sorely disappointed at what ends up at the front door.
Laurie Stone
Janeane, I love online shopping, but it can be dicey with things bought sight unseen. Oh well. Carry on during these Covid times.
Roxanne Jones
I feel your pain! It’s amazing how this never seemed to be an issue when I was younger, but I’ve definitely gotten finickier as I’ve gotten older (and sleeping comfort and aesthetics assume greater importance!). I’ve gone the down comforter/duvet route, then just change out covers (have had good luck with products from The Company Store). And most duvet covers these days have ties to anchor the comforter at the corners so it stays in place. I hope that your quest was finally successful!
Laurie Stone
Roxanne, I’ll look into duvets again. Glad they’ve made them more secure with ties. Mine always end up bunched up at one end.
Janeane Davis
This reminds me of a quest I had for yarn to make a sweater. I looked and looked and no matter what I purchased or tried, it just wasn’t right. I hope you get the perfect comforter soon.
Laurie Stone
Thank you, Janeane. I’m ready to put this challenge to bed, so to speak.
Lauren
I have the perfect duvet and just buy covers for it. So much easier. Try it! This exercise would drive me insane.
Laurie Stone
Lauren, I’m heading in that direction. Duvets can also drive me a little crazy since they shift a lot, but in the long run, they’re much easier.
Rachael Stray
We don’t use comforters as standard here in the UK most of us use blankets or duvets. We have a lighter weight tog during the warmer months and a thicker tog for the colder months. It sound much less hassle and then buying bedding is pretty easy – just need king size. When we had the heatwave we just had a top sheet on. I do hope you find the one!
Laurie Stone
Rachael, I think you guys have it right in the UK. I’m still looking for my comforter!
Jody
I get so picky when I shop for certain things. Hats are one of them. It’s so hard to tell if it’s going to wear right or not or fit the way I want it or hold a shape I like.
Laurie Stone
Jody, Believe it or not, I’m still searching for a comforter. I put the project on hold for a while. I’ll have to rev it back up!
candidkay
Your comforter quest sounds like my perfect pillow quest. I’ve found one that I think is pretty darn good (slept on it in a friend’s guest room) but I’ve yet to find the one that makes me sigh and sleep blissfully:). Good luck on your search!
Laurie Stone
Kristine, Laughing. Good luck on your search too!
Terra
Oh dear, you are on a quest. I was lucky, I bought a comforter a year ago and am delighted with it because it is very light in weight while being warm and the pattern is gorgeous. I hope you have a successful quest.
Laurie Stone
Terra, Sounds like you hit the Holy Grail of bedding. May I be as lucky!
Jennifer
I know this issue very well. My husband and I cannot agree on the same one…so we still have the old one. It’s threads are starting to come loose but for now it’s all we’ve got
Laurie Stone
Jennifer, Poor Randy has had so many comforter “auditions” I think he’s ready to kill me!
Lee Gaitan
Ha!! “My God, since when did I need emotional nuance in my bedding?” What a great line! And, hey, we all have needs. 😉 Good luck and remember it’s better to have a problem with whats on top of your sheets than what’s between them!
Laurie Stone
Lee, Laughing. Leave it to you to get to the very (ahem) heart of an issue. Great way to see it and couldn’t agree more!
Janis @ RetirementallyChallenged
I guess that’s why we use duvets and just buy new covers now and then. Easy peasy… and they never cause rashes.
Laurie Stone
Janis, Duvets are lovely, but always end up bunched up at one end and a bit of a mess. I have yet to hone that technique. Maybe will try again.
Janis
I just safety pin each corner of the duvet to the cover. That seems to work fine.
Laurie Stone
Janis, That’s a good idea. Will reconsider the duvet situation.
Diane
Oh my word! The simplest of tasks taken to Herculean heights!
Husby and I went hunting for a new comforter about a decade ago. Finally found one in a heap carelessly tossed under a table. Not only was it perfect, but it was…perfect! I think the original price was over 700.00. But they sold it to us for 50! So go and look under a few tables. 😉
Laurie Stone
Diane, Wow. That must’ve been a beautiful, luxury comforter if it originally cost $700. You won the comforter lotto! Congratulations!
Bryce Warden
I tried out at least 3 comforters before I found a replacement and it took 2 years to find the one I can live with (not love). I blame the color of our bedroom….it’s one of those that’s hard to match. It’s in the red family but not a true red, leans toward terracotta. It’s nice on the walls damn near impossible if I want a comforter that isn’t a solid neutral. The struggle is real my friend, I wish you luck.
Laurie Stone
Bryce, Yes! The struggle is real indeed. Sounds like you have your own bedding drama going. Good luck!
Rebecca Forstadt Olkowski
That must have been so frustrating. I can relate about the rash. LOL
Laurie Stone
Rebecca, That rash was so strange, never happened before. Lesson learned: wash things first.
Doreen
Oh my goodness, THIS IS SO ME! Comforters, handbags, throw pillows etc. You certainly made me giggle! Good luck on your quest!
Laurie Stone
Thank you, Doreen. I think I’m going to need it!
Lea Sylvestro
I loved this! The writing flowed smoothly and easily (unlike your comforter search) and Ismiled any number of times at the way you portrayed your dilemma. I LOVED “My god, since when do I need emotional nuance in bedding?!” GREAT line, so funny. I hope the box has since been picked up and that you have something comfy and lovely on your bed! XO
Laurie Stone
Lea, Happy to say box was picked up, but still searching!
Diane
Oh the dreaded search for bedding! Husby and I were on the lookout for some nice new sheets. You have to know that our usual sheets-bought by Husby because they were (the magical) ON SALE-were heavy and really only acceptable during the months ending in ‘winter’. I now have some lovely bamboo sheets-light, cool and gorgeous colour-on our bed. But in the closet are several ‘not quites’ and ‘ohmyword what on earth are we going to do with these’ sheet sets. Destined for my kids or the goodwill. Sigh.
Laurie Stone
Diane, We become more set in our bedding ways as we get older, as least I do. Glad I’m not the only one going through this!
Doug M
Omigosh this made me laugh! I gave up quilts a few years ago, now I go with layers of cotton blankets and a throw. It takes a bit longer to make in the morning but easy to lose or gain a layer if I’m too hot or cold. Anyway, the image of that happy quilt sitting outside taunting you.. haha! BTW, I’ve been enjoying some of your older posts, this is a great blog 🙂
Laurie Stone
Doug, Thanks so much for your kind words. Glad I’m not the only one going through bedding drama!