You try and avoid them, but can’t. You hear them in cars, stores, lobbies, elevators, banks, the radio, and on television. They stalk you like bill collectors. They’re everywhere — the most headache-inducing holiday songs. Here are mine in no particular order…
“Santa Baby” by Madonna – Wow. She’s not called the Material Girl for nothing. With all the demands for furs, cars, yachts, and jewelry, there’s something too Golddigger-ish in these lyrics. And while I like Madonna, the itsy-bitsy, cutesy-wootsy baby voice gets under my skin.
Eartha Kitt wrote and performed this in 1953 when women waited for men to buy them nice things, in exchange for “services” of course. Now many working women buy these goodies for themselves, thank you very much. Are there still gold-diggers out there? Hmmm… I’ll leave that to another blog post.
“Santa Claus is Coming to Town” by Bruce Springsteen – Okay fans, calm down. I’ve loved “The Boss” for decades, but he doesn’t always hit it out of the park. What can I say? A musician friend once made fun of this breathlessly cheerful rendition so much, it stayed in my brain forever.
But he was right. There’s something too cutesy here. Plus, how many times must I hear (I believe I counted 24) “Santa Claus is coming to town!” I get it, already.
“Wonderful Christmas Time” by Paul McCartney – Did Sir Paul write this in his sleep? It’s plodding, repetitive and well… sad. Is this the same man who penned “Yesterday” and “Maybe I’m Amazed?” Isn’t the whole song a tedious repeating of the title with some other stuff thrown in?
If you can’t sleep on Christmas Eve, put this on a loop. Trust me, it’s better than Ambien.
“Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer” by Elmo & Patsy – Let’s see… Grandma’s found dead in the snow Christmas morning with hoof prints on her forehead and “Claus” marks on her back? Hi-larious! Grandpa spends the day “Watching football and playing cards with Mel?” Okay. Strange group, back out slowly….
“All I Want for Christmas is my Two Front Teeth” by Spike Jones – Meh. This was cute when I was six and could relate, but so many decades later, I get the message. By now this kid should be 102. Come to think of it, he probably still wants his two front teeth.
“It’s The Most Wonderful Time of The Year” by Andy Williams – Easy for you to say, Andy. You were probably cuddled up in some French ski lodge with sexy snow bunny Claudine Longet when this 1963 ditty came out.
The rest of us mortals? We’re stuck in endless lines at Target. Is this the most wonderful time of the year? Depends when you ask me.
Having gotten that off my chest, here are my three favorite holiday songs…
“Happy Christmas (War is Over)” by John Lennon – The season can’t begin until I hear this. I love the sweetness of the Harlem Community Choir singing backup. I love that John and Yoko snuck in an anti-war message. Even more poignant is that he’s no longer with us. I still miss him.
“The Christmas Song (Chestnuts Roasting)” by Nat King Cole – Many have tried. Many have failed. No one sings this melody like silky-voiced Nat. For some reason the line, “Kids from one to 92” gets me every time. I heard that as a tot and now many (many) decades later, it still makes me misty-eyed. Maybe we all want to believe in Santa Claus.
But the winner is… the song that makes me stop and weep each time…
Charlie Brown’s “Christmas Time is Here” by Vincent Guaraldi.
Those sweet, high-pitched children’s voices… that thoughtful, slow tempo and beautiful melody. This song’s about innocence and childhood lost. (Sorry, I’m already starting to sniffle).
This song isn’t goading you to be cheerful. It’s not about cars and jewelry and furs. It’s not about bumping off an annoying family member.
It’s about time passing.
Remember sliding down a hill on your new sled Christmas morning? Weren’t our children babies just last week, squealing as they came out to see their gifts? Now they’re blasé adults holding coffee mugs.
Where did it go?
For me, Charlie Brown’s “Christmas Time is Here” captures the poignancy of this season like no other. The wheel of life keeps turning.
And yes, it isn’t as exciting as some of the other holiday standards.
But I’ll take it over “Santa Baby” any time. Pass the tissues.
Agree? Disagree? Comments are always welcome.
If you like, please share. If you’d like to receive posts in your email, just push here. Thank you!
Bonnie Aldinger
I actually have no particular dislikes among Xmas songs – the less good ones are innocuous enough that I don’t notice ’em particularly –
But holy cow. Christmas songs en masse, in every store you walk into, from somewhere mid-November on, just because the stores want you to buy stuff??? Soooo wearisome.
I actually love carolling. But the endless holiday cheer as Muzak…I wish they wouldn’t!
Laurie Stone
Bonnie, Yes, Muzak is the worst. I just get sick of the forced cheerfulness. Maybe I’m too Scrooge-y.
1010ParkPlace
Brava, Laurie!! You nailed them… All of them! I didn’t realize how much I liked and appreciated John Lennon’s song until I just now listened to it…. Out of the cornier of my eye I see, “I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas… ” LOL! Must find that one! xoxo, Brenda
Laurie Stone
Brenda, Haven’t heard the Hippopotamus song, although people have mentioned it. Will have to give a listen.
Haralee
Little Drummer Boy was my father’s favorite song with him singing along to the brumpa bump bummm so I always get a bit nostalgic listening to it. Mariah’s, All I want for Christmas is you, gets on my nerves!
Laurie Stone
Haralee, I have to admit, I like Mariah’s song! I play it in my kitchen a lot. I love the little Drummer boy too. That also brings back a lot of childhood memories.
shelley
It’s going to sound really strange, but “I Want a Hippopotamus For Christmas” is one of our favorites. It was one of the ones our kids used to love and sing when they were little and it stuck. Now every time I hear it I see their little faces and it warms my heart. I agree with your picks – Happy Christmas is one I love. Sharing this in a roundup post to publish on 12-16-17.
Laurie Stone
Shelley, You’re so kind. I’ll have to look up “I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas.” That one escaped me somehow.
Shopgirl Anonymous
Oh my goodness I had Grandma got Run Over in my head all season! In all the times I had to review the lyrics with the sadistic voices in my head I have developed theories of what really happened to grandma that cold, dark Christmas Eve. 😉
Laurie Stone
Yes! There are sadistic overtones to that holiday ditty! Glad I’m not the only one who thinks that. Maybe we don’t want to know what really happened to Grandma.
Bun Karyudo
Interesting list. Santa Baby is annoying, but I can just about stand it when it comes on in my local coffee shop. The one Christmas song I really do hate (in any version) is Little Drummer Boy. I know, I know! I’m sorry! I realize everybody else on the planet loves it. I’ve just always found it cloying in the extreme, even when I was little. Luckily, I only have to put up with it for a couple of weeks at a time.
Laurie Stone
Crazy world, Bun, because I like “The Little Drummer Boy!” Thank God we’re now done with the holiday songs. Now its onto surviving the next four years.
Candidkay
Oh, John Lennon gets me teary-eyed every darn time with that song. And I always seem to hear it on Christmas Eve or close to it, in the car on a snowy night:). Wishing you a very Merry Christmas! And a good playlist:).
Laurie Stone
Yes, I have the same thing happen, Kristine. This song always sneaks up on me Christmas eve or Christmas day. It always slows me down and makes me appreciate this holiday. I really love it.
Molly Stevens
Little drummer boy is the song that drives me crazy Laurie. All that pa rump pa pa pumming puts me over the edge! I do love your three favs. And Carol of the bells is one of my top 10. Great post.
Laurie Stone
Thanks so much, Molly. I must confess, I like the Little Drummer Boy! Its funny how we all feel differently about the various songs. Thanks for reading.
Jennifer Dunham
This made me laugh! I love getting to Christmas music but I will say I get a little bit tired of hearing the same songs over and over.
Laurie Stone
Thanks, Jennifer. Glad I’m not the only one!
Heather
Any version of “Santa Baby”, “Wonderful Christmas Time” and Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas” are my least favorite Christmas songs. I love “Celebrate Me Home” by Kenny Loggins. It just transports me. I also love “O Holy Night.” Fun topic!
Laurie Stone
Heather, I also like “Oh Holy Night” and “Silent Night” for that matter. Never heard Kenny Loggin’s song. Will have to check it out. I have to admit, I like Mariah’s “All I Want for Christmas.” Think its kind of fun and zippy. But its all subjective! Thanks for reading.
Diane
The worst for me is ‘The Red Shoes’ or whatever it’s called. The most manipulative song ever! And don’t even mention ‘Baby, It’s Cold Outside’. Seriously, don’t mention it or it’ll be stuck in my head for another four days!
Laurie Stone
So funny! “Baby its cold outside,” is getting a bad rap lately because of its “date rape” overtones. I’ve read many bloggers lately that have weighed in and find it strange. Thankfully, its never been on my playlist, but there’s nothing worse than getting a song stuck in your head.
Megan
I agree on the Paul McCartney one … it drives me crazy, and hearing covers of it is even worse. It’s a terrible song! Why are we perpetuating it?!
No disrespect to John Lennon when I say I cannot STAND “Happy Christmas (War is Over).” I know it represents what he stood for and all. But it drips with cynicism, as if our world doesn’t have enough of that already on the other 364 days of the year. Just my opinion!
Laurie Stone
Megan, No worries. We all agree to disagree. Songs are personal and evoke different things in different people. Thanks for commenting!
Pam
I agree with your worst Christmas songs list but would add- I WANT A HIPPOPATOMUS FOR CHRISTMAS (seriously HATE that song, it’s so annoying) and HAPPY CHRISTMAS (WAR IS OVER) (I have no idea what it is about this song but I can’t stand it…could be from overplay?) and FELIX NAVIDAD (definitely from overplay on the radio!) and take off IT’S THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME OF THE YEAR. Have you heard CHRISTMAS TIME IS HERE sung by Lyle Lovett and Kat Edmonson? It’s my favorite since last year. Now, it’s getting overplay on my Spotify playlist. Haha! This was a fun post!
Laurie Stone
Pam, Will have to try “Christmastime is here” by Lyle Lovett. Never knew it existed. Never heard of the “Hippopotamus song” either. Will have to investigate!
Lisa @ The Meaning of Me
Hate Santa Baby. Ugh!
I do love the McCartney and Williams ones, though. Childhood memories.
Charlie Brown Christmas CD is our number one favorite!
Laurie Stone
Lisa, The “Charlie Brown Christmas” set gets me every time, especially “Christmas Time is Here.” So beautiful and such an interesting choice of music for a children’s show.
Leanne@ www.crestingthehill.com.au
Santa Baby would top it for me too – just grossly inappropriate really. All I want for Christmas was pretty dumb until my daughter in law sent me a pic of my grandbaby’s two top teeth coming through in time for Christmas – now I have a little more fondness for it 🙂
Laurie Stone
Leanne, The “two front teeth” song probably does get cuter with a grandchild or two! I’m glad I’m not the only one who hates “Santa Baby.” That was the first that sprang to mind.
Beth
Oh, I hate “Santa Baby.” You know what’s worse? We just watched White Christmas (one of my favorite songs BTW), and that stupid song “sisters” has been on an endless loop in my head now. Blerg…
Laurie Stone
Beth, I’m glad I’m not the only one who hates “Santa Baby.” I also like “White Christmas,” the Bing version of course! Thanks for reading.